Weak ADP Data Leaves Fed in Limbo

Advertisements

  • December 22, 2024

In recent months, the American labor market has shown signs of coolingA significant report released by the U.SBureau of Labor Statistics on June 4 indicated that job vacancies in April dropped to 8.059 million, marking the lowest level since February 2021. This downturn has prompted analysts to reevaluate the current state of employment in the United States.

The day following the JOLTS report, the Automatic Data Processing (ADP) Company revealed that the American economy added only 152,000 jobs in May, the lowest in three months and substantially below the forecast of 175,000. This was adjusted down from April’s figures, which saw a revision from 192,000 to 188,000, signaling a deceleration in job growth.

The ADP employment report, often dubbed the "little nonfarm payroll" report, serves as a precursor to the more widely anticipated nonfarm employment data due for release

This upcoming report is expected to indicate an increase of 190,000 jobs in May, while the unemployment rate is projected to remain steady at 3.9%. Despite these anticipations, the labor market appears to be exhibiting a more subdued performance than before.

Further analysis of the labor market data contributes to expectations that the Federal Reserve may soon opt for rate cutsSwap market indicators reveal that traders have shifted their expectations for the Fed’s first rate cut, initially anticipated for December, to NovemberSome traders are even beginning to prepare for potential cuts in SeptemberThe movement in these markets reflects growing speculation about a shift in monetary policy in response to economic indicators.

This sentiment has extended to capital markets, where U.STreasury bond prices have risen, with yields significantly decreasing

On the day the JOLTS data was released, the yield on ten-year Treasuries dropped nearly 10 basis points, reaching a three-week low, while shorter-term two-year Treasury yields fell nearly four basis points, marking a five-day decline.

As the Federal Reserve enters a silent period before its next meeting, the fluctuations in Treasury yields are expected to continue shaping market trendsThis period of anticipation surrounding the Fed's decision making could be telling of future economic conditions and interest rates.

The JOLTS report articulated a dismal picture of the job market, where job vacancies at the end of April were recorded at 8.059 million, falling short of the expected 8.35 millionThis brought the job openings to unemployment ratio down to 1.2:1, the lowest since June 2021. It indicates that there are now only 1.2 available jobs for every unemployed individual, a stark departure from the tighter labor market conditions seen in previous years.

Drilling down, the healthcare sector saw vacancies plunge to a three-year low, while manufacturing jobs dropped to the lowest point since the end of 2020. Additionally, demand in government roles, as well as accommodation and food service industries, has also diminished, hinting at a broader slowdown in hiring across diverse sectors.

When looking beyond vacancies, other indicators have remained relatively stable, with voluntary resignation rates holding steady at 2.2% for the sixth consecutive month

This suggests that while job openings may be down, workers are not flooding the job market in search of other opportunities.

The ADP employment report corroborated the notion of a weakening labor market, demonstrating a downturn in growth due to stark manufacturing contractionsFurthermore, year-over-year wage growth remained stagnant at around 5%, the weakest figure since 2021. Notably, wage growth for job switchers fell to 7.8%, marking the second consecutive month of decline.

Nela Richardson, ADP's chief economist, noted that as the second half of the year approaches, employment and wage growth are slowing"The labor market is solid, but we are monitoring pronounced weaknesses in sectors related to producers and consumers, with nearly all hiring coming from the services sector," she explained.

Fed officials seem hopeful that this gradual cool down can persist, allowing them to control demand and curb inflation without triggering a wave of layoffs

alefox

Unlike drastic layoffs, this measured approach could potentially stave off mass unemployment and its associated social implications.

In a report, Goldman Sachs trader Cosimo Corda-Pisanelli suggested that expectations of a recent Fed rate cut will be driven more by the state of the labor market than by falling inflation ratesFed Chair Jerome Powell had previously indicated that any "unexpected" deterioration in the labor market could prompt earlier-than-expected rate cuts.

Scheduled for release on June 7, the Labor Department's May employment report will illuminate key figures such as official nonfarm payroll growth and unemployment ratesPresent market expectations point towards an increase of 190,000 non-farm jobs and a stable unemployment rate of 3.9%. Market participants remain keenly observant of the Federal Reserve’s next steps as economic indicators emerge.

As the Fed maintains its watchful stance, balancing inflation control and employment stimulation remains central to its mission

Recent mixed economic data has further clouded the Fed's rate-cut outlook.

Last week's most-discussed data showed significant downward revisions in both GDP and personal consumption expenditures growth for Q1, indicating a slowdown in the U.Seconomic momentumThe latest Beige Book released by the Fed concluded that while the economy has continued to grow, rising uncertainty and risk concerns have subsequently dimmed the economic outlook.

Conversely, inflation continues to remain elevatedMost economists predict that core inflation indicators, such as the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and Personal Consumption Expenditure (PCE), will not return to the Fed's target of 2% before 2026.

As the week unfolds, the ISM reported that the U.Smanufacturing Purchasing Managers Index (PMI) fell to 48.7 in May, its lowest in three months and below the expected 49.6, a clear sign that manufacturing activity has been contracting at an accelerated pace.

Simultaneously, the Markit manufacturing PMI released earlier showed a final value of 51.3 for May, exceeding expectations of 50.9, demonstrating conflicting signals in the data that could perplex analysts and the Fed.

Such mixed data creates a complex narrative, as expectations surrounding the Fed's interest rate decisions appear to ebb and flow

Earlier in the year, markets were betting on a March cut that shifted to June, then further delayed to SeptemberJust a month ago, traders were doubting any rate cuts for the year, but now confidence has rebounded regarding potential cuts by year-end.

Dan North, a senior economist at Allianz Trade, observed that "U.Sinterest rates have risen to a fairly high level, slightly moderating the labor marketHowever, on the other hand, the U.Seconomy remains relatively strong."

This mixed performance could elucidate why the Fed is opting for a more cautious approach.

The Fed's next meeting on interest rates is scheduled for June 11-12. Economic consensus indicates that no significant changes will be made at this time despite hopes for eased monetary policyMeanwhile, traders expect only a 14% chance of a cut during the July 30-31 meeting, while prospects for a September cut appear just above 50%.

Additionally, a Reuters poll indicated a majority of economists foresee the Fed's first rate cut in September, but there remains a possibility that rates may be cut only once or not at all.

As speculation surrounding the U.S

Treasury's future ensues, questions regarding the implications of rising Treasury yields persist.

Previously, Fed Chair Powell expressed skepticism about falling inflation, emphasizing prolonged monetary policy might be necessary, demonstrating a more hawkish stance.

This perspective is reflected in rising Treasury yieldsRecent commentary from Wellington Management investors indicated that expectations for the Fed to lower rates in 2024 have been slashed from six to just one or two cuts due to unexpectedly high inflation dataYields on ten-year Treasuries surged over 80 basis points from the beginning of the year until the end of April, with the Bloomberg U.SAggregate Bond Index showing approximately -3% return.

The elevation of Treasury yields triggered a sell-off in risk assets across markets

This trend affected global sovereign bonds alongside the U.Smarket as the response to U.STreasury auctions remained tepid, with both long and short-term notes drawing lackluster demand.

This situation reflects market concerns about the escalating U.Sdebt and delayed expectations for rate cutsThe persistent high interest costs for the federal government signal ongoing challenges for market participants regarding the risk of investing in short-term debt.

Following the ADP report, on June 5, benchmark ten-year Treasury yields fell by 3.89 basis points to 4.2871%, while two-year yields retreated by 4.19 basis points to 4.7285%. This decline marked a continuation of the trend initiated after the release of the JOLTS report, signifying a warming sentiment towards rate cuts.

Historically, rate cuts have allowed for bond appreciation, typically viewed favorably for the bond market

However, with concerning employment data and the PMI figures now in circulation, traders worry that any Fed intervention in rates might stem from the need to rescue a struggling economy, posing a risk to future bond value predictions.

As interest in U.STreasuries takes center stage, active investment strategies against such complex economic backdrops emerge as critical subjects of consideration for investors.

Despite potential disappointment following the Fed's continued pause on rate cuts, market analysts from Wellington Management caution that valid reasons for holding bonds remain intactThey point to the historical precedent observed in the tightening cycle from 2004 to 2006, where investments in bonds performed well even amid delayed rate cuts following the last hike in June 2006.

They conclude by urging investors to consider reallocating cash towards bonds, given the Fed's historical tendency to maintain stasis for extended periods, including a lasting period of 15 months without modification during the 2004-2006 tightening cycle.

Comments (82 Comments)

Leave A Comment